Ditch the Duopoly: Ad Networks Beyond Meta and Google That Print ROAS | SMMWAR Blog

Ditch the Duopoly: Ad Networks Beyond Meta and Google That Print ROAS

Aleksandr Dolgopolov, 25 December 2025
ditch-the-duopoly-ad-networks-beyond-meta-and-google-that-print-roas

Retail Media Gold Rush: Cart Stage Audiences With Purchase Intent

Cart-stage shoppers are gold—literally. They've added product, shown intent, and are seconds away from converting, so retail media networks that plug into checkout and cart signals can hit ROI in ways broad-audience buys rarely do. Tap into retailer DSPs and on-site placements to leverage SKU-level data, point-of-sale trust, and a compressed path to purchase that tends to print real ROAS faster.

Make it tactical: mirror the exact cart contents in your creative, suggest complementary SKUs, or trigger one-click discounts that remove friction. Prioritize inventory-aware creatives that hide out-of-stock items, run rapid retargeting windows measured in hours not weeks, and favor dynamic product ads over generic banners—cart intent decays like fresh bread, so speed and relevance beat cleverness.

Use first-party signals—loyalty IDs, checkout events, coupon redemptions—and stitch them to cross-device identifiers to boost match rates and attribution accuracy. Start with conservative bids, tight frequency caps, and creative variants testing price badges, stock warnings, and CTAs such as Complete order or Save at checkout. Above all, measure incremental revenue with holdout groups so you're optimizing for lifted sales, not vanity metrics.

Quick three-step playbook to win at cart-stage: (1) ingest cart and SKU signals in real time and build micro-segments; (2) deploy dynamic creatives with urgency and inventory logic; (3) run short A/B holdouts to prove incremental ROAS, then scale winners. Diversify your ad stack, pilot fast, and let revenue — not assumptions — steer your retail media bets.

Community Commerce: Win High Intent Traffic on Reddit and Forums

Community spaces funnel purchase intent differently: people arrive to solve problems, not to mindlessly scroll ads. Show up with relevance and respect and conversion velocity climbs. Treat subreddits and niche forums like tiny search engines — tune titles, answer threads, and seed proof early. The payoff is warmer clicks and stronger ROAS compared with broad cold targeting.

Practical moves you can execute this week: map 5–10 micro-communities where your product actually solves a pain, then listen for 48 hours before engaging. Use contextual offers in comments, host an AMA with a genuine team member, and run disciplined, low-frequency native creatives that match community tone. Always disclose partnerships; authenticity converts better than cleverness alone.

Creative and offer templates that work best for community commerce:

  • 🚀 Intent: Short, problem-first headlines that match thread language and include a clear micro-CTA (coupon, guide, demo).
  • 👥 Trust: Real-user proof: screenshots, short testimonials, or a brief case note — no glossy slogans.
  • 💬 Scale: Lightweight followups: DM offers, pinned comments, and a tracked landing page to capture intent and remarket.

Measure what matters: track micro-conversions like product page visits, coupon redemptions, and DM inquiries with UTM-tagged links and tight attribution windows. Segment ROAS by subreddit and thread so you can double winners and kill losers fast. For paid boosts, favor placements in high-comment threads or moderator-approved slots where social proof amplifies clicks.

Quick three-step playbook: 1) Run a $500 pilot split between organic engagement and native ads; 2) A/B value-first headlines and two proof formats; 3) If CPA holds, scale into similar communities and lock in top-performing creatives. Community commerce is less about interruption and more about being useful — win that and the rest prints.

CTV and Streaming: Big Screen Reach Without Big Tech Pricing

Think big screen without the big ad tax: connected TV and streaming let you hit living rooms with the size and attention of linear TV but with modern targeting and far more pricing flexibility than the usual duopoly bids. Instead of fighting inflated CPMs in crowded exchanges, you can buy curated inventory on FAST channels, AVOD apps, and programmatic CTV deals that reward smart creative and audience layering more than deep pockets.

Start by treating CTV like an upper-funnel engine that can still drive ROAS when paired with a conversion plan. Test 15–30 second creative variants that end with a clear action, map households to site visits with server-to-server pixels and postback events, and set strict frequency caps so you get reach without burnout. Use private marketplace deals or direct-sold IOs for brand-safe inventory and predictable CPMs, then feed conversions back into your DSP for optimization.

  • 🆓 Free: Launch a low-cost FAST pilot to benchmark CPM and view-through lift against your paid social baseline.
  • 🐢 Slow: Reserve a portion of spend for guaranteed buys that build steady frequency and measurable brand recall over several weeks.
  • 🚀 Fast: Layer first-party audiences and in-flight creative swaps to push immediate CPA gains and scale winners quickly.

Make measurement your secret weapon: run holdouts to prove incremental lift, stitch CTV exposure into your multi-touch models, and prioritize partners that share granular logs. Do this and you get big-screen scale, cleaner inventory, and better ROAS—no monopolies required, just smarter media moves.

Contextual Targeting 2.0: Cookieless Performance That Scales

Move past brittle cookie fences by using semantic signals that actually describe intent. Contextual Targeting 2.0 blends page taxonomy, content sentiment, session behavior, device signals, and inventory quality to find moments when people are ready to engage. You reach users by what they are reading and doing rather than by an opaque identifier. The result is less waste, higher relevance, and faster paths to conversion.

For cookieless performance you want deterministic, privacy safe inputs. Leverage publisher first party data where possible, enrich with deterministic identity graphs and session scoring, and bake viewability and time on page into your bid logic. Build creative variants that match context rather than relying on audience cookie profiles. Test headlines, imagery and CTAs that mirror the article or video theme to boost engagement and lift click through and post click conversion rates.

Start small with an inventory map and a seed set of contextual categories tied to business outcomes. Run conversion lift tests with control and treatment arms that segment by context, not by user cookie. Monitor ROAS, view through conversions, average order value and incremental conversions over time. Use those signals to prune low yield placements and to expand into adjacent contexts that show consistent uplift.

Swap ad platform dogma for quick experiments: run parallel buys on specialized ad networks and contextual providers, iterate creative based on context performance, and shift bids toward environments that deliver the best incremental ROAS. Scale budgets gradually and automate rules that push spend to high performing contexts at set thresholds. Treat contextual as a growth lever that scales across publishers, protects privacy, and prints measurable returns.

Direct Buys and DSP Hybrids: Smarter Spend With Transparent Fees

Stop throwing half your ad budget into black boxes: direct buys and DSP hybrids give you placement-level clarity and fees you can actually explain at dinner. With direct buys you buy guaranteed inventory on publishers and apps; with hybrids you stitch programmatic reach onto those guaranteed seats so your campaign mixes predictability with scale. That mix is a ROAS-boosting secret.

Start by carving out a pilot: 10–20% of testable media to direct buys, another 10–20% to a DSP hybrid with capped fees. Negotiate an insertion order that lists media cost, tech fee and viewability guarantees. Ask for weekly placement reports and run identical creatives across both channels so you can isolate performance differences without mystery.

Make measurement obsessively simple. Use first-party audience signals, server-side conversion capture and unified attribution windows to compare apples to apples. Push partners to expose line-item CPMs, creative-level KPIs and traffic sources. If a vendor refuses transparent line items, treat their pitch like a fancy invoice — interesting to look at, but risky to scale.

Here is a one-week experiment: A/B the best-performing creative in direct buys versus the DSP hybrid, keep frequency caps equal and track ROAS daily. If direct buys outperform, scale the publisher relationships; if hybrid wins, optimize bid strategies and lower tech fees. Either way you will spend smarter, with fewer surprises and a better bottom line.